← Back to Blog

Social Media Manager vs Marketing Manager: Who to Hire First

Disclosure: boomp.net is ours, and it is one of the options on this page.

You have room for one marketing hire, and the two job titles sound alike. Hire a social media manager first when you already know who you sell to and what you offer, and the accounts go quiet whenever work gets busy. Hire a marketing manager first when nobody has decided what the business promotes, or when your website, emails and posts each send people somewhere different. If you already make those decisions yourself and the only stalled job is making the posts, you may need neither, because that one job costs from $9 a month in software. Write down the work that is not getting done before you choose a title.

What each role owns

The titles overlap in small businesses, so compare the work.

A marketing manager owns the plan. The Bureau of Labor Statistics says marketing managers "estimate demand and identify potential markets for products and services," and that they "may develop pricing and other strategies, such as ways to acquire and retain customers" (Occupational Outlook Handbook, read November 19, 2026). In a small business that means deciding which customers to go after, what to offer them, what to say, and which channels get the time and money. A marketing manager often directs other people or vendors to carry the plan out.

A social media manager owns one group of channels. O*NET, the Department of Labor's occupation database, describes the work under public relations specialists. The closest task there is "Post and update content on the company's Web site and social media outlets" (O*NET, read November 19, 2026). In practice a social media manager plans the posts, writes or gathers them, publishes them, and often answers comments and messages. The role carries a plan out. It does not include writing one unless you add that to the scope.

The workMarketing managerSocial media manager
Deciding which customers to go afterOwns itWorks from the answer
Choosing what to promote this quarterOwns itWorks from the answer
Prices, offers and promotionsOften owns or advisesNot in the role
The website and its pagesDirects changesNot in the role
Email to customersPlans it, may write itNot in the role, unless you add it
Ads and the ad budgetPlans and directsSometimes runs social ads, if scoped
Planning and writing social postsSets the directionOwns it
Publishing on a scheduleNot usuallyOwns it
Answering comments and messagesNot usuallyOften owns it, if scoped
Reporting what workedAcross all channelsFor the social accounts

When the plan is already on your website

You may have already done the marketing manager's hardest work. If you chose your customers and your offer years ago, and your website says so, the stalled job is turning what the website already says into posts.

A real example

This post was published through Boomp from the agent's own website. She is a listing agent on the West Michigan lakeshore and a paying customer, shown without her name.


Copper gutters on a blue house with the lake behind it.
Published August 30, 2026.

Curious what buyers in Saugatuck are quietly willing to pay more for?

It isn't the granite or the brand-new appliances.

It’s outdoor living that actually works in July.

A usable deck, a screened porch, mature trees for shade, or a yard that flows toward the water.

Buyers here start picturing June through September the second they walk in.

A home that delivers that feeling gets the stronger offer.

If you’re prepping to list, don’t pour your entire budget into the kitchen and ignore the backyard.

A clean, staged outdoor space changes the math more than most sellers expect.

When you bought your place, was it a room inside that sold you, or the way it felt when you walked out the back door?

The post names a town, a kind of buyer and advice for sellers. No new plan was written to make it.

Find the gap before you pick the title

One list can show you the gap. Write down the marketing work that did not get done last month, then see which column it falls in.

If this is trueThe gap isHire or buy first
You cannot say which customers you most want, or what to lead withThe planA marketing manager, or part-time senior direction
Your website, emails and posts each give a different next stepThe planA marketing manager, or a monthly marketing partner
You have a plan and several channels, and nobody coordinates themRunning the planA marketing manager or a marketing coordinator
The plan is clear, and the social accounts need planning, posting and replies every weekSocial mediaA social media manager
The plan is clear, and the only thing that stalls is getting posts madeOne job inside social mediaSoftware or a posting service, not a manager
Social media is where your customers buy, ask and complainSocial media, as a full jobA social media manager, before anything else

Two warnings come from the same list. A social media manager hired into a business with no plan has nothing decided to post about. A marketing manager hired into a business that only needed posts is paid to make decisions the owner has already made.

A worked example

This is a worked example, not a customer. Say you run a local service business. You know which service you want to sell more of, and your website explains it well. Posts stop every time work gets busy.

If you need one person to plan the posts, publish them and answer the replies, that is a social media manager's scope. If visitors arrive but the service page, the follow-up email and the posts each ask them to do something different, the whole path belongs in a marketing manager's scope. If the path works and you only need posts made, hand a provider your service page and the questions customers ask, and check the drafts against those sources.

What each option costs

These figures come from named sources, and each describes something different, so read the middle column before the price.

Who does the workWhat the figure describesThe figure
A full-time marketing managerMedian annual wage for marketing managers (Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2025, read November 19, 2026)$166,790
Part-time senior marketing directionPublished hourly and retainer rates, in our fractional CMO guideSee the guide for each source
A monthly marketing partner (Local marketing or Marketing partner)An agreed monthly list of work across search, Google Business Profile and social$900 or $1,800 a month
A social media manager on your payrollAverage base salary for a social media manager (Payscale, read November 2, 2026, as recorded in our pricing study)$61,083 a year
A freelance social media managerSample billing for an intermediate, US-based specialist managing two channels for a small business (Upwork, read November 2, 2026)$400 to $2,000 a month
A person reviews software-made posts (Social, handled)The posts, reviewed and scheduled to your connected accounts$275 a month
Software that writes and publishes posts (Boomp Pro)28 posts a month, which you approve in the app$79 a month
Software that writes the posts (Boomp Packs)Ten finished posts, which you publish yourself$9 a month

The wage figures are national and cover businesses of every size. Neither figure is a quote for your business. On these sources the marketing manager is the larger commitment of the two.

How to hire for the gap you found

  1. List the work, not the title. Write the ten things you want done each month. If most are decisions, you are hiring for the plan. If most are tasks on one channel, you are hiring for social media.
  2. Mark what you will keep. If you keep the decisions about customers, offers and prices, say so in the job post, so candidates know the role carries the plan out.
  3. Do not ask one person for both. A post that asks for strategy, a website, email, ads, design, video and daily posting describes a department. Pick the half that is stuck.
  4. Ask each candidate what they would not do. A good social media manager will say they do not set your prices. A good marketing manager will say they should not be the one posting every day.
  5. Test with real work. Give a marketing candidate last quarter's numbers and ask what they would stop doing. For a social media candidate, use the paid sample in how to hire a social media manager.
  6. Check who they have reported to. A social media manager who has only worked under a marketing lead may need direction you do not have time to give.

For the full hiring process once the role is clear, see how to hire a social media manager. For the choice between an employee and an agency for the wider role, see in-house marketing vs agency.

When you need neither yet

You need neither when you already make the marketing decisions and can name the single job that keeps slipping. Hand off that job. A manager's salary pays for judgment and coordination, and one recurring task does not need either.

This is also where Boomp fits, and where it does not. Boomp is software that reads your public website and writes social media posts about your business, with images. It does not decide who your customers are, set your prices, run ads, plan email or reply to comments. If your gap is the plan, Boomp will not close it, and a marketing manager or a marketing partner is the right first step.

What stays with you

Whoever you hire, the facts and the final say stay yours. Check prices, hours, service areas and offers before anything goes out. Get permission before a customer's name or photo appears anywhere. If you work in a regulated field, such as health care, law, finance or real estate, read every post before it publishes and keep auto approval off.

Choose the work you want handled

Packs at $9 a month sends ten finished posts with images, written from your website, by email link. You publish them yourself, with nothing connected.

Pro at $79 a month includes 28 posts a month, four of them short videos, and the post mix changes over time. They are published to your connected social profiles and Google Business Profile, with Google Review monitoring and performance notes. You approve each post before it goes live, unless you turn on auto approval. Core at $39 a month includes 22 posts.

Social, handled at $275 a month gives you the Core posts with Kathleen, Boomp's founder, reviewing every post before it publishes, and help with social setup. You connect your accounts from a link we send and do not need to open the app. If your gap is wider than social media, Local marketing at $900 is the plan we recommend: it adds Google Business Profile updates, a review-request process sent to every customer, one new or improved search page and up to two small website updates a month, inquiry tracking and a monthly progress update, for one business at one location. Marketing partner at $1,800 adds a second search page, one customer email, one offer page or promotion and a monthly planning and progress call. Both start with a 15-minute call, and the work is agreed before payment. No plan includes ads or ad spend, replies to customers or reviews, or photo or video shoots. The done-for-you plans are 90-day plans, billed monthly, and you can stop any month.

Start with ten finished posts from your website, with images, a carousel and a short video, sent by email link with no account or card.

Frequently asked questions

Is a social media manager the same as a marketing manager?

No. A social media manager runs one channel group: planning posts, publishing them, and often answering comments and messages. A marketing manager owns the plan across every channel: who the business wants to reach, what it offers them, what it charges, and how the website, email, ads and social posts work together. In a small business one person sometimes holds both titles, so ask what the person will own, not what the title says.

Should a small business hire a social media manager or a marketing manager first?

Hire for the gap you have. If you know who you sell to and what you offer, and the accounts go quiet when work gets busy, the gap is in social media. If you cannot say which customers to go after, or the business has no agreed next step for a new visitor, the gap is in the plan, and a marketing manager or a part-time marketing lead comes first.

Can a social media manager do my marketing?

A social media manager can run your social accounts. Setting prices, choosing which customers to pursue, rebuilding a website and planning email are a different job, and one job post that asks for all of it describes more than one role. If you need those decisions made, write them into the scope and hire for them, or keep them yourself.

Do I need a marketing manager if I already know my customers?

Often not yet. If you already decide who to reach, what to offer and what to charge, you are doing the marketing manager's main work yourself. What you may need is someone or something to carry out one part of the plan, such as social posts or a monthly email. Hire for that part and keep the decisions.

What does a marketing manager cost compared with a social media manager?

The Bureau of Labor Statistics puts the median annual wage for marketing managers at $166,790 in May 2025. For social media, Upwork's sample billing for an intermediate, US-based specialist managing two channels for a small business is $400 to $2,000 a month (read November 2, 2026). The two figures describe different things, a yearly wage and a monthly bill, so compare the work each one buys before the price.

What if I only need the posts made?

Then you may not need a manager of either kind. Making posts is one job inside a social media manager's role. Software can do it from your website, and Boomp's plans start at $9 a month for ten finished posts. If you want a person to review every post before it publishes, the Social, handled plan is $275 a month. You keep the decisions about what the business promotes.

See what Boomp would say about your business

Ten finished posts made from your website, sent to your email. No account or card.

Make my free posts

Rather not do this yourself? Start with alternatives to hiring a social media manager or an agency versus done-for-you.

Doing it yourself? The AI you already pay for can help with landing pages, a website audit or press and PR.

Save this to Pinterest

Social Media Manager vs Marketing Manager: Who to Hire First
KC

Written by Kathleen Celmins

Founder of Boomp. Helping local businesses stay visible on social media without doing the work themselves.